LRT Link Research Tools

Expedia.com: FULL deep-dive into Unnatural Travel Link Schemes [update +250%]

56 Comments
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...
Expedia.com: A deep-dive into Unnatural Travel Link Schemes

The Full 250% Deep-Dive into Unnatural Travel Link Schemes of Expedia.com

Expedia has been hit hard with a Penalty and lost 25% of its visibility. Even a Negative-SEO attack was suspected. This FULL deep dive by Bartosz Góralewicz which now contains 250% more details and content than the preview looks into the backlink profile of Expedia and reveals tactics they got away with for quite a while. Bartosz walks you through the reasons Expedia experienced such a traffic drop.

We look forward to your feedback and always appreciate you sharing the work of our Certified LRT Professionals ;)

- Enjoy & Learn!

Christoph C. Cemper

PS: As usual in our deep-dives, we try to give site owners, customers, and interested SEOs, clues on what to look for and how to use LRT to identify backlink profile risks. We assume Expedia is currently cleaning up a lot of their backlink profile. Therefore, we hope this case study helps them also.

Bonus PDF: Bartosz Góralewicz also put together a “Tutorial on how to process 120M link exports”, you can get it FOR A TWEET HERE

Table of Contents

Expedia – Google Penalty for black hat links?

It all started with a single post of an angry SEO – Nenad at http://nenadseo.com/new-seo/. After receiving a manual penalty from Google for 2 small sites (according to his post, one of which had only 3 links, 2 being no-follow). He started pointing out that “big players” could buy low quality links and get away with it. As his example, he used www.expedia.com.

The post gained huge popularity in the SEO community, but it looked like Matt focused on AngloRank during that timeframe.

expedia.com tweets nenadseo mattcutts

Exactly one month later, there was a large drop of 25% in Expedia’s visibility in SearchMetrics around Jan 19.

expedia.com searchmetrics

Expedia’s visibility dropped from 773,776 to a low of 551,548 (SearchMetrics visibility metrics).

And actually on Jan 26 we saw another drop of ~5% to 521.568.

expedia.com searchmetrics

In Sistrix, the drop was visible a couple days later due to index refresh intervals. They’ve noticed almost a 20% visibility index drop.

expedia sistrix ranking drop

sistrix visibility index

Expedia’s Google ranking drop in press.

The mainstream press covered this penalty like no other before. Some examples are:

Quick look at the backlinks

What did Expedia do wrong?

Just after some quick research, I’ve found some really suspicious links. First I thought it was a clear negative SEO attack on Expedia.com. There were loads of link networks, sponsored low-quality articles, and WordPress Themes with a hidden link to www.expedia.com etc.

Soon enough, somebody else found the links too – and suspected a negative SEO campaign as such links are really high risk these days.

was expedia targeted by negative seo

Was it really a negative SEO campaign?

You can find the links mentioned above, by simply googling “Designed by the Expedia Cheapest Flights Team.” At the time of writing this case study, there are 3.650 pages indexed in Google with “Cheapest flights” links inserted.

Google search designed by expedia cheapest flights team

By Googling that, you will find WordPress blogs with a “Travel Blogger” theme. Some of them use an old, old SEO “trick” of using black text on a black background (!). Example below.

WordPress blog with expedia.com links injected

Isn’t that a little bit “last season?” Matt Cutts wrote a post about Hidden links on April 17, 2007 (!). It was so odd that I actually believed that it might be a sneaky, negative SEO attack by their competitors. But when I looked closer at those WordPress blogs with “negative SEO” links, something wasn’t quite right.

I looked closer at the WordPress Theme. It was created in 2011. Why would somebody build negative SEO for 3 years? WordPress theme “Travel Blogger Theme for WordPress” was created March 18, 2011 and from day one it had PHP code to inject into Expedia’s links.

expedia.com injected wordpress theme

expedia.com wordpress theme

OK, somebody might say, that it was a “long running” negative SEO campaign.

However, I found the owners of the site with the WordPress theme for download. It wasn’t too hard. After checking the registrant in DomainTools.com, this is what came up:

Domaintools freetravelwebsitetemplates.com registrant

http://myersmediagroup.com re-directed me to http://www.enterpriseseo.net/. After a quick look around the site, this is what caught my attention:

enterpriseseo.net clients

So unless this site is a huge scam, there was not any “negative SEO” attack. Creating a WordPress Theme with a keyword rich footer is not new, it is actually a little bit of 2008 – 2009 SEO. Definitely black hat and definitely outside of any Google Webmaster Guidelines – back then and more than ever today.

“Negative SEO WordPress-Theme”

The WordPress theme changed recently after the ranking drop was noticed. Also, there is one more interesting thing. The day after www.expedia.com dropped in rankings, there was a “Travel Blogger” theme update. Some might think it is a coincidence, but let’s see exactly what changed between versions. There is a nice comparison online that reveals the exact changes (removed/changed code is red. New is green).

Let’s see what has changed in version 1.7.

changelog expedia wordpress theme

“Sponsored links” was removed. Now it is a little bit more white hat.

changes wordpress theme travel blogger

changes wordpress theme travel blogger

Footer links:

removed links changes wordpress theme travel blogger

Also, 20 keyword rich links were removed here:

removed links changes wordpress theme travel blogger

Actually now, the word “expedia” is not present in this updated theme at all. So basically, on January 20, 2014, the theme was “wiped” clean from everything that could have brought Expedia into trouble.

Did Expedia only get punished for the WordPress theme link injection?

The answer is simple – NO. There were so many black hat techniques used to get/buy links for www.expedia.com.

Black hat links used by www.expedia.com

Expedia’s Link network 1

Shady auto-generated hotel sites, usually with domain names that are exact matches for the keywords they target. The low quality of those sites might even make it more of a link farm, than a link network.

I’ve noticed that they are removing these links from this network. Some of them disappeared while writing this case study.

http://www.cheap-hotel-rates.biz/United-States/Oregon/SEASIDE/city-hotels.aspx

original-email

expedia risky link network

http://www.cheap-hotel-rates.info/United-States/California/OCEANSIDE/city-hotel-prices.aspx

expedia risky link network

Expedia’s Link network 2

There are many link networks behind www.expedia.com. In fact, Link Research Tools makes it so easy to spot them, that I will just reveal two of them and show you how more can be easily found.

Looking at many of the backlinks, I’ve spotted sites, which were clearly part of a network. For example – http://thejokeshop.org/. It is pretty clear to me that it is not a real joke site. Mainly, because there are many jokes with 2 keyword-rich links. One to Wikipedia or some other authority site (the classical “co-citation link”), and a second one to, for example – www.expedia.com.

expedia.com link network example

How to spot a link network behind www.expedia.com using Link Research Tools?

It is an easy 5 – minute process. All we need is only 1 site linking to www.expedia.com that you are sure is in a link network. Now, we just need to take 6 more external links from this site. Now, let’s paste those 7 links into CBLT (the Common Backlinks Tool).

expedia.com common backlink tool to uncover link network

After that we click Run Report

expedia.com common backlink tool to uncover link network

And we get our link network on “display.” I always feel a little bit like Matt Cutts while doing that.

expedia.com common backlink tool to uncover link network 3

expedia.com common backlink tool to uncover link network 4

expedia.com common backlink tool to uncover link network 5

After 5 minutes, I found more than 700 domains that we are can be sure, a lot of which are a part of a link network (of course excluding feedburner.com). All of that out of only 1 domain.

Examples of sites in this network:

http://comcatalyst.org/

link network comcatalyst.org

http://www.brokerscostarica.com/?s=hotel

link network brokerscostarica.com

Also, there are some examples of the links that would be definitely out of Google Webmaster Guidelines.

Sponsored advertorials

Clearly a paid link or advertorial. Paid links should be no-follow and not pass Page Rank.

http://www.jasminedirectory.com/regional/north-america/

directory links jasminedirectory.com

Paid guest blogging with low quality posts.

Buying links from “bloggers”, as it was pointed out by NenadSEO, is usually a keyword – rich anchor simply “injected”, even if there is not much logic in it. NenadSEO described that technique in-detail in his post.

  • http://entreprenomics.com/top-5-tips-for-business-travel/
  • http://www.cheaptravelblog.net/6-of-the-most-enjoyable-theme-parks-in-the-nation/
  • http://thecharmingblog.com/2013/09/24/5-attractions-see-yourself-usa/

Directory submissions

http://petdirectory.com.ar/America/Puerto_Rico/?s=H

Real spammy, submissions in free or paid online directories. On the screenshot below you can see English description and English keyword-rich anchor in a directory from Argentina. The directory is based on a popular PHP Link Directory. In this case site that is not even fully configured and translated.

directory links petdirectory.com

http://globalresourcedirectory.biz/pages/globaltower/global_businesstravel.html

directory links

Sponsored articles or Press Releases with do-follow, keyword rich links

Links below are not as bad as link networks above, but clearly out of Google’s guidelines.

Press releases should be no-followed.

  • http://www.informationweek.in/informationweek/pr_newswire/236447/vacations-boost-pleasure-expedia-study
  • http://goodmorningindia.asia/vacations-boost-pleasure-expedia-study-finds
  • http://indiabroadcast.in/vacations-boost-pleasure-expedia-study-finds
  • http://theindiannews.in/vacations-boost-pleasure-expedia-study-finds

Looking at the data above, it is pretty clear that www.expedia.com is not a case of a negative SEO attack. Most of the actions are run by an agency that they’ve hired or even in-house.

Some of these tactics might have been implemented years ago. As recommended since the launch of Penguin in 2012 it’s crucial that you perform an ongoing link risk management on your backlink profile and even disavow on a cautionary, pro-active basis, which has even been confirmed by Matt Cutts.

Keyword-targeted manual penalty?

After releasing first part of this case study, I started wondering if I missed something. If they have a manual penalty from the Google Search Quality Team, and it is a partial penalty (not like in the Rap Genius case study) then it might be “assigned” to a keyword that dropped in rankings. Let’s investigate a little bit into that.

Below you can see a screenshot of “lost” keywords from Expedia. If there was a manual penalty, then it is definitely connected to the keyword “travel” and “flights”.

expedia.com traffic drop keywords travel and flights

Now let’s look into Sistrix index.

As we can see below, http://www.expedia.com/Flights got hit really bad, losing almost 50% visibility. http://www.expedia.com/Cars lost almost 60% visibility.

expedia.com flights drop on sistrix

expedia.com cars drop on sistrix

Hypothesis – why did www.expedia.com have such a traffic drop?

In my opinion, www.expedia.com got a manual penalty for 3 keyword “groups”.

  • Flight
  • Travel
  • Cars

Also I think the penalty was “connected” to Expedia’s WordPress theme. If my hypothesis is right, there are 3 kinds of WordPress themes by Expedia. For Flight, Travel and Cars, the keywords that lost visibility in Google.

Let’s see if we can prove, that this hypothesis is right by analyzing keyword by keyword.

Flight keyword

It is clearly connected with the WordPress theme links, pointing to http://www.expedia.com/Flights, like this one http://www.hudsondogpark.com/

WordPress theme with cheapest flights links

Let’s take a look at the link.

WordPress theme with cheapest flights links code

“Flights” related keywords got penalized most probably after “discovering” the WordPress theme by Googlers. Expedia’s recent actions seem to confirm this hypothesis.

Travel keyword

Now, let’s find links with “Travel” anchor. If my hypothesis is right, we should find another WordPress theme with “travel” keyword in footer.

How to find only backlinks with a defined anchor?

For that all I need to do is run a Quick Backlinks Tool (QBC). And look for a “travel” keyword.

Link Research Tools Quick Backlinks 01

Link Research Tools Quick Backlinks 02

Link Research Tools Quick Backlinks 03

Link Research Tools Quick Backlinks 04

Now we can have a look at the links found. Let’s look if there is any pattern that could cause a manual penalty for the “travel” keyword. If you look closely at the screenshot above, there are links with “/Links.html” and “/Resources.html”. If I were a Google employee, those are the first ones I’d look at.

Let’s take a closer look at those links.

http://www.eatonfuneralhomes.com/Resources.html

eatonfuneralhomes.com link

http://www.tighehamilton.com/Links.html

tighehamilton.com link

http://www.douglasandjohnson.com/Links.html

douglasandjohnson.com link

http://www.ccshepherd.com/Links.html

shepherfuneralservice.com link

http://www.fournierandfournier.com/Resources.html

fournierandfournierfuneralservice.com link

Looking at the sites above, there is a clear connection between all of them. But I got some mixed feelings about the nature of those links. They’re are not “clearly” black hat links. That is why I would like to dig deeper into “travel” and “flight” keywords.

I still want to find a WordPress theme with a “Travel” keyword. Doing it with a site that has more than 130,000,000 backlinks to go through would take me days.

What if the keywords are not there anymore? Let’s remember that this whole story started in December 2013. Expedia is probably reacting to their organic visibility drops, including the bad publicity and dropping stock prices.

I started looking at the “source”. When I opened the site http://www.freetravelwebsitetemplates.com/ offering the Travel Blogger WordPress theme with Expedia’s links, I didn’t find any links to www.expedia.com. That got me thinking. They use so many black hat links, why wouldn’t they link to their website from Page Rank™ 4 travel site?

Free travel website theme

As you can see above, there is NO FOOTER. Now let’s take a look at a footer in the screenshot below. It is a screenshot from site in Google’s cache. Snapshot of a site from 9th January 2014.

http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:4nQKZOh-7TkJ:www.freetravelwebsitetemplates.com/update-permalinks/+&cd=3&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=pl

footer google cache travel blogger theme

Free travel website theme

Do you remember the screen with www.expedia.com keyword drops?

expedia.com traffic drop keywords travel and flights

Now let’s compare it with their WordPress free theme update.

We have a “Travel” keyword.

changes wordpress theme travel blogger removed links

We found more than 3600 links for “cheapest flights”

Google search designed by expedia cheapest flights team

All we need now is “Cars” keyword.

Cars keyword

This one was actually the hardest one to prove. I was getting close to giving up on my hypothesis.

I’ve decided to start a backlink profile (BLP) only for the sub-page http://www.expedia.com/cars. This way I will only get the links to the page that dropped in Google.

LRT Backlink Profiler Expedia.com Cars

Again, as in example above, I search only for links with “cars”, “car rentals” etc. in anchor.

expedia cars search

Now, let’s take a look at one of the links:

http://derabwesendeheld.de/

expedia wordpress theme with rental cars

expedia wordpress theme with rental cars code

Daily Directory Drop

Look at the address above: www.expedia.com/daily/cars and now let’s check it in Sistrix. If my hypothesis is right, expedia.com/daily should have dropped significantly.

sistrix daily expedia drop

A second “bonus” is that we can now track all the other related WordPress sites.

footprint cars

Now we have a “footprint” of Expedia’s Rental Cars theme. Let’s check if we can find more of them.

Great (not for Expedia though), we got 1160 more links within 0,37 seconds .

footprint cars google

Expedia’s current SEO “situation”

Bingo! My hypothesis was right. In my opinion Expedia’s main problem is and was WordPress themes created for footer links from Travel sites. There are many other factors, but none of those are as serious and as black hat as this one. Also they’ve lost only ~ 20 – 25% organic visibility, what makes me suspect keyword-targeted manual penalty.

It is hard to show a full “spectrum” of Expedia’s linking profile. Not only because the site is so large and complex, as Link Research Tools really helps in sorting it out, but mostly because most of the links in “their power” are now being removed.

There were many examples that I wanted to expose in this case study, but the links “disappeared” over the weekend, which is a good sign that Expedia is acting on this. Fortunately in many cases, Google Cache was there to help us show some indicators for us researching tough.

Is Expedia changing their SEO strategy?

At the moment of creating this case study, it really looks like there are some drastic changes “in process” at Expedia.

Link Removal

Clearly, there are some changes visible you can see while looking at their SEO strategy and existing links. E.g. MajesticSEO shows a lot of lost links starting from January 12, 2014.

This could be a crawling issue also, but most likely Expedia is already on a cleanup-spree for weeks.

I don’t know how quick they are reacting, but after spending many hours looking at their backlinks and changes, I think, they’ve started a cleanup around 12th January 2014. Before this date, most of the links, that they had a full control of, were still visible. After 12th, most links started disappearing.

With site this big and this many links, link profile cleanup could take months, but I guess Google will not “hold” the penalty for too long. Recent cases such as Rap Genius did show us, that everything goes quicker with big brands.

Below you can see their link removal with up to almost 40,000 links per day.

WordPress blog with expedia.com links injected

Changes in a WordPress theme they’ve created are really going to impact their link profile. As soon as WordPress owners update their theme, links are going to disappear.

The WordPress “link strategy” might also backfire in this case. Many of the sites using this theme seem to be abandoned. Removing the links from them might be difficult. Expedia will of course disavow them, but we all know, that the showing effects and effort is crucial to lifting a penalty.

If you use the “TravelBlogger” theme, you can be almost sure that your site which helped Expedia’s visibility for years may now “land” in an Expedia.com disavow file with “domain:” in front of it.

On-Page changes

I am not going to get in-detail into their on-page changes, I just want to mention some of the things I’ve noticed.

The agency working for Expedia.ca site left many minor “bugs” that they are now fixing. A couple days ago, www.expedia.ca was linking out to a staging site with do-follow links. It seems to be fixed now, but you can still see the links in Google Cache (I don’t think they are cloaking, it just looks like it was not indexed and cached yet). This for example is a cached page – This for example is a cached page -

http://rental-cars.expedia.ca/chihuahua-car-rentals-mexico/class/suv-rental-cars/

on page results

Also, there are staging sites left by the agency “on display” with links pointing to them.

http://rentalcars-production-us.myersmediagroup.com/car-classes/

on page results for expedia

And the “real” one:

http://rental-cars.expedia.com/lhr-airport-rental-cars/

on page results for expedia

I checked the IP for the staging site. It is on Expedia’s server. That is a 100% proof that the agency responsible for the WordPress theme is officially working for Expedia.

on page results for expedia

Expedia’s link profile

What I covered above, was more of an “investigation” than a real look at Expedia’s link profile. I must say that after checking all the stuff “manually”, I cannot wait to see how it looks when looking at the whole link profile.

After what I saw above, I wouldn’t expect the DTOX to be “bad”.

OK, let’s run it then.

Have in mind that we are only running a small, representative % of links here. Full DTOX of 120,000,000 we got would take a long time to process and even longer to analyze. We even had problems with processing 120,000,000 links on a regular PC.

We’ve eventually found a way (ways) to do it. If you want to know how, we wrote up a whole “Tutorial on how to process 120M link exports” get it FOR A TWEET HERE

Competitive research

We all know that travel, hotels and flights are not a “clean” niches. Let’s see how Expedia looks compared with the competition.

Competitive Landscape Analysis

CLA (Competitive Landscape Analysis) for “cheap flights” top 10.

competitive landscape analysis for expedia

competitive landscape analyzer for expedia

find competing pages for expedia

competitive landscape analyzer for expedia 4

competitive research report for cheap flights

Now, let’s take a look at 11 domains we got listed below.

Farecompare and Momondo got a score of 12 CEMPER Power*Trust™ which is really low for such a competitive niche. It is definitely a factor worth looking into in these companies.

Expedia has a a CEMPER Power*Trust™ score of 35 with CEMPER Trust™ higher than CEMPER Power™ so I wouldn’t look for any problems here and focus on further increase of those numbers.

Tripadvisor is a clear winner with CEMPER Power*Trust™ of 63, and a really high CEMPER Trust™ of 9 (!). If I were creating a new SEO strategy for Expedia, or even mentioned before Farecompare and Momondo, I’d definitely take a closer look Tripadvisor’s backlinks and strategy.

domain compare for cheap flights

Let’s take a look at comparison by CEMPER Power*Trust™. Even a quick look shows that, Expedia doesn’t “fit” into average score from top10.

Why would Expedia have such a “spike” in that area? I can only guess, that it is connected with a linking strategy mentioned earlier. I am suspecting, that the spike is caused by links from WordPress theme with injected links. But at any rate, it sticks out and looks a bit unnatural.

metric comparison by CEMPER Power*Trust

Let’s move forward to CEMPER Trust™ metric. We got a dangerous factor here, worth looking into. If we look at the chart, it’s quite obvious that Expedia “stands out” with Trust metrics much higher than competition’s average in range between 8 and 12.

competitive landscape for cheap flights

The problem I would try to solve here is with the many sites with 0 Trust. Expedia has 31% sites with no trust metrics, when competition average is 16%. That is almost 200% more. It is definitely a factor worth fixing in future by Expedia’s SEO team. Sites with 0 trust are usually new, or really low quality. This is definitely the worst “area” of the chart to have this much more links than competition. Sites with 200% weaker or lower quality links than average can definitely raise flag in Google, which we obviously don’t want.

Now there is one more interesting thing I found in this CLA.

competitive landscape for cheap flights

We can clearly see above that there is a huge difference to the average in every type of Keyword. The most worrying is only 6% Money keywords, comparing to 34% average for Top 3. That means that Top 3 average has 560% more money keywords than Expedia.

metric comparison by link status

Do-follow to no-follow distribution is also worth looking into. Expedia’s got 6% more do-follow links than Top 3, Top 5 and Total average.

metric comparison by link type

Some more image links than competition, but I wouldn’t worry about the score here. It is pretty close to top 10 average.

metric comparison by deeplink ratio

40% Startpage Link to Deep Link proportion. Also a little bit different here than average. From what I saw in the links, it is mainly because of the Expedia’s site structure with many landing pages like www.expedia.com/Flights for flight related searches and http://www.expedia.com/Hotels for hotel searches etc. I think we shouldn’t look at this factor as good or bad. Expedia.com must be more complex site than Cheapoair.com as Expedia offers also hotels, cars etc.

metric comparison by google author id

In my opinion, here CLA “reveals” what NenadSEO wrote in his post about Expedia buying articles from bloggers. Bought links from blogs are a large part of Expedia’s SEO strategy what we can clearly see above.

metric comparison by sitewide ratio for domain

The Sitewide Ratio for this domain confirms the WordPress theme links strategy of Expedia.com sort of, and while there are quite a lot of site wide links popular in the travel space as we can see, Expedia sticks out again.

CLA (Competitive Landscape Analysis) for “Travel” top 10.

Expedia.com had also a huge traffic drop for “travel” keyword. Let’s see the competition in the field and how Expedia’s link profile fits into it.

Competitive Landscape Analysis for Travel

Competitive Landscape Analysis for Travel

As shown above, Expedia is a leader in here in amount of referring domains. Only TripAdvisor has a better score.

What should raise a flag here is that Expedia has more than twice as many referring domains as Kayak.com or Orbitz.com while their CEMPER Power*Trust™ is much higher. 49 for Kayak.com and 42 for Orbitz.com, while Expedia.com has a score of only 35 CEMPER Power*Trust™. This clearly indicates that Experia.com is getting many links from low authority and power domains.

metric comparison by CEMPER Power*Trust

As we can see above, Expedia’s link profile has a huge spike with 76% links being 8-12 Power*Trust™. What is in my opinion caused by WordPress Theme links.

metric comparison by DeepLink Ratio

This is a really interesting screenshot that made me include “travel” CLA in this Case Study. If we compare it with the “cheap flights” CLA, we can clearly see, that those niches are completely different.

Let’s take a look at the same comparison from “cheap flights” niche.

metric comparison by DeepLink Ratio

As you see, those are two completely different niches with a different competitors. It is a challenge to compete in both of this markets and after recent Expedia traffic drops, I think they are going to look closer into this problem.

Link Detox (DTOX) for Expedia

Let’s run a DTOX then for www.expedia.com

Link Detox for Expedia

Now, we need to classify as many keywords as possible. We are aiming at a score higher than 80% to have best DTOX accuracy.

Link Detox Keyword Classification

After classifying as many keywords as possible, we need to reprocess the report with new keyword classification and we got our Average Link Detox Risk. First, let’s take a look at the scale.

Link Detox Risk Ratings

Link Detox Average Risk

The overall risk is not high for www.expedia.com. It is far from exceeding 1000, where it could be classified as potential Penguin Victim. What we learn here is that the “AVERAGE” link risk is just that, an average, weighted by a couple factors, but this is the reason why Expedia got away in the Penguin updates.

There are still many links, I would take a closer look at.

Link Detox Risk Breakdown

As we can see above, out of the links we checked, 6% is High Risk or higher. If we scale it to all the links we found for expedia.com, that would give us 6% out of 120 million – 7.200.000 links. More than 7 million possible toxic links (!).

Have in mind, that it is only a “partial” detox. While working on this case study we didn’t have enough time to properly process more than 120 million links. It would require more time to process and then properly analyze such amount of links.

Link Detox Summary

Link Detox sitewide filter

We filtered only 4793 links out of 101.578 cause or really excessive site wide linking to www.expedia.com

What is an interesting fact is that www.expedia.com has 80 links from every linking domain on average! This is quite common and shouldn’t be worrying in travel niche, as there is a lot of partner sites linking with widgets or offers.

Link Detox for Expedia’s subdomains

But Expedia.com is a complex site with many subdomains. Some of them are worth mentioning here.

Rental-cars.expedia.com – DTOX

For example, let’s take a closer look at subdomain http://rental-cars.expedia.com/. As we know Rental Cars is one of the keywords that lost visibility recently.

Link Detox Deadly Risk rental-cars.expedia.com

Link Detox Risk Breakdown rental-cars.expedia.com

Subdomain has Link Detox Risk score of 1658, making it a Deadly Risk and a potential Penguin victim. With almost 60% links with High – Deadly Risk!

Flights.expedia.com – DTOX

Another keyword that significantly lost SEO visibility.

Link Detox Deadly Risk flights.expedia.com

Link Detox Risk Breakdown flights.expedia.com

Link Detox Summary flights.expedia.com

Hotels.expedia.com – DTOX

Link Detox Deadly Risk hotels.expedia.com

Link Detox Risk Breakdown hotels.expedia.com

Link Detox Summary hotels.expedia.com

As you can see looking at those 3 subdomains above, there is a lot of link cleaning for Expedia’s SEO team. We don’t know if those subdomains were penalized, but those are sure Penguin candidates.

Good things at expedia.com

It turns out that somebody at Expedia.com still believes that “content is the king”. After spending some time with them, I found one really good asset – viewfinder.expedia.com

good things at expedia.com

good things at expedia.com

After taking a closer look, I think they really focused on quality there. Hiring really good guest bloggers, creating interesting articles and offering good terms for new bloggers.

Unfortunately, many things lead me to believe Expedia’s Marketing and SEO team are in two different buildings or even states.

There are a lot of great articles. However, they are filled with keywords. Too many keywords. While reading such a “stuffed” article, you start to think this article was written as a result of an SEO saying “write an article on: Romantic winter experience, New York City, Big Apple, Jacques Torres Chocolates, La Maison du Chocolate and Pairing Classes.”

good things at expedia.com

Expedia has a lot of interesting and quality content. Even the size of the site (4 million pages indexed in Google), gives them a huge advantage. I am sure after recent problems, Expedia is going to start using their potential; without the dirty tricks and cheap “keyword stuffing”.

Conclusion

This is a deep dive into Expedia’s linking and SEO strategy. After looking at Expedia and their competitors, I think that if NenadSEO didn’t create a post that went viral in the community, Expedia could have got away with its SEO strategy for quite a while.

What we see above clearly shows that www.expedia.com is most probably not hit with algorithmic penalty, what again confirms my hypothesis about manual action after revealing their linking tactic. Some of the subdomains are a perfect candidate for a Penguin penalty, but Expedia’s traffic drops are correlated with main page and subpages.

I think that if Expedia is going to work with Google on removing the penalty, it is not going to take a long time before they come back in rankings. The Search Quality Team at Google will achieve its goal and Expedia is going to put a little bit more effort (and budget) in creating their SEO strategy.

While working on this case study I received some emails and messages from people struggling with this huge player in the travel industry. They were all trying to focus Google’s attention at what is going on in this niche for a long time.

While looking at the whole of Expedia’s link profile, I knew was room for improvement in many fields. I think that this traffic drop is going to be influential for Expedia. A fresh start with a better strategy, one that is not based on a spammy blogs or WordPress themes with link injection. These are all SEO techniques from many years ago and as we know in SEO world, strategies or SEO “trick” that is 4 – 5 years old are basically a negative SEO.

What is also important to notice, Expedia is “cleaning” its link profile as I write this post. It means that even when the penalty is lifted and their rankings come back, they are not going to regain their “old” positions and visibility straight away.

That leaves room for new players in travel industry and from the feedback I had during my work on this case study, I know that there are many new players looking for a fair chance in travel niche.

What do you think about this research?
Please comment below

This case study was written by Bartosz Góralewicz, SEO Consultant, Online Marketing Specialist, and proud user of Link Research Tools and Link Detox.


A word from Christoph C. Cemper

Certified LRT Professional This analysis was conducted and post written by our new Certified LRT Professional, Bartosz Góralewicz.

Bartosz showed proficiency in doing a SEO link audit on the current topic of Expedia’s penalized SEO strategies. I am thrilled by the detail and structure he accomplished in his case study. Therefore, I’m very happy to certify Bartosz Góralewicz as the latest Certfied LRT Professional; by approving and publishing his research on our site.

Our goal is to provide our user community and clients with quality service and knowledge. Our Certified LRT Professionals are key to achieving this goal.

I look forward to his future work, and personally recommend Bartosz Góralewicz to work with you, whenever you get the opportunity!

And if you wonder what it takes in hours and coffees to put this post together and achieve the honored status of CLRTP, then you should read Bart’s “Behind the Scenes of the Expedia.com LRT Case Study” post.

Certified LRT Professional Bartosz Góralewicz

This analysis was created using our Superhero Plan and the new Competitive Link Detox tool extensively. The Superhero plan allows you to perform professional SEO and backlink analysis for your own or your competitor’s sites. If you only need Competitive Link Detox (CDTOX), that’s also included in all new Link Detox Pro plans and up.

Don’t miss our next FREE LRT Associate Training. Get one of the last spots if you’re up for 8 hours of free professional training with Christoph C. Cemper.

Don’t forget to signup for our notification list to get informed on other Case Studies on Google Penguin updates.

Are you ready for for the next Google Penguin Update?







Bartosz Góralewicz

Bartosz Góralewicz specializes in link audits. He does consulting mostly for corporate customers and large sites. You can find some of his case studies or interesting posts at http://goralewicz.co

Bartosz Góralewicz

Bartosz Góralewicz

Bartosz Góralewicz
Google Penguin 3.0 is here any day.

Hire one of our 29 Certified LRT Professionals, Certified LRT Xperts and Certified LRT Agencies to conduct your Penguin 3.0 link audit – TODAY.

56 Comments

  1. Nenad January 24, 2014

    Hi Bartosz

    I was reading some article on your blog few days ago and I liked one article and wanted to comment, but for some reason this was not possible…anyway, I was now checking where the visitors are coming from (to our site) and noticed a link from this site, so I came to see what is it about and saw this great article.
    I am glad that you covered all these tactics cause this is exactly what i found out, I especially like that blackhat Free WP themes site. Imagine, free themes with premium support, and all they want is a footer link to stay intact.
    When I was checking out these links I saw (among others) “Galvestone Hotels” and when you search for that KW Expedia is either 2nd or 3rd spot on the first page.

    The agency that was doing this for Expedia was so sure nobody is going to follow their works that they didn’t want to hide their footsteps. And they were tapping each other on the back all the way to the bank for the last 5-10 years.

    Google webspam team is a major Joke

    reply
    • Bartosz Góralewicz January 28, 2014

      Agency mentioned here is pretty “strange”. They are impossible to find, no backlinks (only from non-indexed staging sites). No SEO done in SEO agency? I think they are somehow connected to Expedia, but no idea if its true.

      Good job starting this whole thing Nenad!

      reply
  2. Dan January 25, 2014

    Excellent analysis. I’ll be looking forward to the link detox part :D

    reply
  3. James January 25, 2014

    Dude, this is fantastic. It’s like baseball, if players don’t do steroids, it won’t be a level playing field. Same thing in highly competitive online marketing.(travel, education, IMO,MMO etc….

    I’m glad that Google is standing by their terms.

    Props on this post!

    James

    reply
    • Bartosz Góralewicz January 29, 2014

      Thanks James, I am affraid, that this whole niche should be “cleaned” by Google a little bit.

      reply
      • Michael Korolishin February 4, 2014

        Hopefully they take on the Fitness and Health industry next…I have an inkling it’s just as bad, if not worse than the Travel and Hospitality industry.

        By that, I mean it’s currently a full-blown fucking mess.

        reply
  4. eldy January 25, 2014

    will seo specialists receive salary bump? they are like the key man for a raise and down in a company, like we see in rap genius and expedia.

    reply
  5. PackmintonR January 25, 2014

    It is about time. There were times when I felt the hand of injustice from Google. Big names have always got free of the penalties while little ones suffer.

    I guess this is sending signals out to other big names to review their link building strategies.

    Thanks for this post and the analysis.

    BTW. Cemper’s tools are awesome but EXTREMELY EXPENSIVE!

    reply
    • Michael Korolishin February 4, 2014

      While I agree that Google needs to come down on some of these big brands using questionable tactics, as well as make it easier for SMBs to recover when they are hit with an automatic penalty, I think we should take into consideration the actual impact of some of these manual “penalties”.

      Rap Genius is a great example, because the entire thing felt like a manufactured PR stunt from both parties – I still believe it may have been one. I mean, let’s think about what actually happened. That Google penalty lasted for barely 2 weeks, hardly the experience shared by many SMBs who are hit with automatic penalties. On top of this, the sheer amount of press around the even actually lead to Rap Genius’ organic link profile GROWING..at a rate faster than they had ever experienced in the history of the company. Now Rap Genius is using this wave of free press to launch their own App, and they are firmly back at the top of Google search results, even after running the single most asinine link building scheme seen this side of Expedia.

      It’s important to remember that Google is in the business of providing the best platform for advertisers, everything else is ancillary to, or a direct result of this fact. Rap Genius was too big, and too popular for Google to keep off the web for long because of the amount of PPC related to the keywords they rank for.

      reply
  6. Johan Hedin January 25, 2014

    Interesting case study. Just like any other big site like BMW that was penalized many years back, came back very quickly. I think it will be the same for Expedia. It’s amazing that Expedia got all these low quality back links and they did not even know it. Did they ever check their GWT? If it was a not a negative attack, then I guess they have learned a lesson not to use cheap SEO tactics.

    reply
  7. Amit January 25, 2014

    It will be really interesting to know about Expedia’s Link management and Link cleaning strategy.

    reply
    • Bartosz Góralewicz January 29, 2014

      There is a massive clean-up going on now, but I doubt they will talk about it. :)

      reply
  8. Rick Lomas January 25, 2014

    I have a handful of clients that I am trying to recover at the moment – mostly Penguin 2.0 and 2.1 drops. The weird thing is that they have mostly been sold SEO services that said “White Hat Penguin Safe Tactics”. Clearly risk management and knowing your battlefield is more important than ever now. I’m always stunned by how huge companies like Expedia, Interflora and Direct Line can manage their risk so badly. It’s all good new for LRT Associates Like myself though :)

    reply
  9. Steve January 25, 2014

    Nice work Bartosz! Not a good idea to have the same listing in a few hundred directories then?

    reply
    • Bartosz Góralewicz January 29, 2014

      It depends – if you got a short term strategy, that might work well (for a short time) :)

      reply
    • Bartosz Góralewicz January 29, 2014

      If you got a long-term SEO strategy, then I wouldn’t do that.

      reply
  10. Matthew Boley January 25, 2014

    That will teach them… I am surprised that they didn’t get hit long ago. It’s amazing though how many companies I run across when researching why a company is on top are actually performing black hat. The financial or loan niche is the worst out of all of them I have found. Great write up, I am glad I don’t use any of those tactics lol.

    reply
  11. Rotimi January 26, 2014

    Great work Bartosz,
    I am shocked to hear that you still have more digging to do on this matter.
    Talk about being in-depth and thorough.
    Kudos to you on your efforts.

    I hope to read more SEO reports from you in the future. And thanks for this one.

    reply
    • Bartosz Góralewicz January 28, 2014

      Thanks Rotimi,

      Actually there was a lot more work, and I hope it’s more clear to see in the full version. I’ve spent hours and hours researching Expedia’s backlinks. When I found one thing, it was like opening the doors with many other doors behind it. I think its and endless research, so we tried to focus on the main problems here.

      reply
  12. Magnus Strømnes Bøe January 27, 2014

    Great effort to show what actually happened.
    Looking forward to the results of further digging.

    reply
  13. Jerry January 27, 2014

    What might be really interesting is to see how the bounced back from the penalty. I can still see them rank highly for a few keywords.

    reply
  14. Abdul Wahab January 28, 2014

    Interesting findings. Most interesting point is Google took action after nanad’s blog. Its a question mark to Google’s algo.

    Waiting for next findings in this

    reply
  15. Krzysztof Furtak January 28, 2014

    Brawo:)

    reply
  16. Brett T. Smith January 28, 2014

    I’m glad that Nenad exposed what Expedia was doing. Big brands need to be treated with the same slap that a small business site would receive. Unfortunately based on what I can tell, these big brands can get away with this type of stuff. Another example is GoDaddy http://goo.gl/ARoX3Z (thanks to @ViperChill)

    reply
  17. sourabh rana January 29, 2014

    Hello Bartosz,

    Thanks for this case study as a travel company we also aware & cautious about these kind of link building programs. Last year cheapoair.com also penalized like this but this is really pretty big penalty.

    I checked his total link profiles they have 92crores external inks acc. to majestic seo database. ( very very huge)

    YES, we are waiting will google give them ranking again in just few days like google did with other top brands in past like rap genious & interflora.com

    reply
  18. Massimo Fattoretto January 30, 2014

    Great Analysis

    Thanks:)

    reply
  19. Charlie @ ClickProz February 3, 2014

    Yet the author of this article has a dofollow signature link in his author bio. Interesting.

    reply
    • Bartosz Góralewicz February 3, 2014

      Matt Cutts said it many times. It is the end of “low quality” guest posts blogging. He even mentioned that it is targeted towards paid guest blogs and you should only let someone you trust do a guest blog. I don’t see this case study as a way of getting 1 do-follow no-anchor link to “fool” the algo :)

      It is important to see a difference between spammy WP template with hidden links, and 1 no-anchor do-follow link from a quality post. IMHO links like the one in my BIO are exactly ones that Google should consider as a quality ranking factor. Not the other way around.

      reply
  20. Chande February 4, 2014

    Hahaha. I’ve been doing travel for years and this is nothing new. But now SEO community backfired to the hypocrisy of Google and sank Expedia. I would not like to be the manager who approved spamming for them. But I guess with so much $$$ in the pockets, they’ll clean up and get the rankings back.

    With manual tweaking by Mr. Cutts and “no-spam” team.

    Poor guy will be the collateral damage. VPs will still earn big checks. Investors will regain faith once the results are up.

    Time to invest in expedia stock.

    What a joke.

    reply
  21. @mmeisner February 4, 2014

    http://t.co/CFg7UxylKi: the FULL deep-dive into Unnatural Travel Link Schemes [250%+ update] http://t.co/ZxPKUjyR4A very detailed expose

    reply
  22. @stuartdmcleod February 4, 2014

    Expedia has been hit hard with a Penalty and lost 25% of its visibility, find out why –
    http://t.co/kwrwhAUSWr

    reply
  23. @ben_beck February 4, 2014

    THIS –> http://t.co/zdlBr3J5es: the FULL deep-dive into Unnatural Travel Link Schemes http://t.co/YEY058R4J9 http://t.co/Q8LzSih1nI

    reply
  24. @jonaslindblom February 5, 2014

    Spännande länkanalys kring vad som hände med Expedia #svSEO http://t.co/FLkyY44v6C

    reply
  25. @815seo February 5, 2014

    http://t.co/vlbH7DBD5p: FULL deep-dive into Unnatural Travel Link Schemes [update +250%] http://t.co/yGKiUAh2Jm via @cemper

    reply
  26. @iamjoona February 5, 2014

    This was an epic read of sneaky stuff that big sites can/could get away with: http://t.co/kiwUxmdbST #seo #fuckthisshit

    reply
  27. @alfina87 February 5, 2014

    http://t.co/AxZrclobWR: FULL deep-dive into Unnatural Travel Link Schemes http://t.co/1hYGZp6fWL via @cemper #blackhatseo

    reply
  28. Victoria Lennon February 5, 2014

    Brilliant article and very thought provoking!

    I wondered if you had any thoughts/opinion as to why Expedia managed to get away with using these out-dated techniques for so long (and why other brands are too)? Surely some of it would have been penalised after Penguin? It’s depressing for those of us who are adhering to the guidelines!

    reply
  29. @bart_goralewicz February 5, 2014

    “@alfina87: http://t.co/mmGeh1G6LO: FULL deep-dive into Unnatural Travel Link Schemes http://t.co/2W05UhKXoJ via @cemper #blackhatseo”

    reply
  30. @kwaimind February 5, 2014

    Wow! In Depth case study – http://t.co/UtW1jQ3vWw: the FULL deep-dive into Unnatural Travel Link Schemes – http://t.co/xOXz6qDZEd

    reply
  31. @tomyches February 5, 2014

    http://t.co/zftN3vAEp1: FULL deep-dive into Unnatural Travel Link Schemes [update +250%] http://t.co/IRt8a48USq vía @cemper

    reply
  32. @JakubMovic February 6, 2014

    http://t.co/7wSYoix8nX: FULL deep-dive into Unnatural Travel Link Schemes [update +250%] http://t.co/iZLdqV9ndh via @cemper

    reply
  33. @wkaczanowski February 7, 2014

    as always great case study from @cemper : Deep-dive into Expedia´s Unnatural Link Schemes http://t.co/UF7j7apxJj

    reply
  34. @samsonmedia February 7, 2014

    This is a WILD story about Google’s smackdown of Expedia and why. Reads like a whodunnit. http://t.co/uSIia8skoP

    reply
  35. @samsonmedia February 7, 2014

    This is a WILD story about Google’s smackdown of Expedia and why. Reads like a whodunnit. http://t.co/uSIia8skoP http://t.co/qUxM3sBsp3

    reply
  36. @kesbutters February 7, 2014

    http://t.co/T8o9tpJVfA: FULL deep-dive into Unnatural Travel Link Schemes [update +250%] http://t.co/vnkuMis7OW via @cemper

    reply
  37. Durant Imboden February 8, 2014

    Mind-boggling analysis. Good work! Now, if only a whistleblower could supply an analysis of how these schemes were allowed to happen (and of how high in the company the corrupt SEO schemes were approved).

    reply
  38. Spook SEO February 11, 2014

    All of this was MMG’s fault why Expedia drop down this last January. That was the Expedias major breakdown.

    reply
  39. Jonathan Hatton February 12, 2014

    Absolutely superb analysis.

    Very interesting to see the level of work put into link building they have done.

    reply
  40. @Pro_Ice May 25, 2014

    Очень интересное чтиво — расследование использования Expedia грязного SEO с WordPress-темами: http://t.co/ItlhHeyowT via @cemper

    reply
  41. @KarineHeyden June 19, 2014

    @NinaHendy Google it? SEO fraternity? Ever seen this http://t.co/4OuuwhAYWg or this http://t.co/Rnsa2wXFd6

    reply
  42. @joannavaiou July 17, 2014

    http://t.co/tZIcBWdN4f: FULL deep-dive into Unnatural Travel Link Schemes [update +250%] http://t.co/EtvMUuZko0 via @cemper #seo #seolinks

    reply

Leave a Comment

 

Compare Plans and Pricing

Check out our other tools

 
LinkResearchTools is trusted by the world’s most respected brands.
adobe
mtv
ebay
intel
swarovski
yahoo

Especially the Competitive Landscape Analyzer is just incredible. I cannot imagine doing linkbuilding without Cemper's toolbox.

Dimitri Tarasowski, CEO at aQvisit.com

Link Research Tools from Christoph Cemper not only delivers the game play book, but the strategic operational manual for success. You just need to supply some sweat and then reap the rewards.

Jason Duke, Founder of StrangeLogic