EN | DE | Contact Us +43 720 116 440+1 866 347-3660+44 800 011 9736+31 85 888 1541+353 76 680 1480+1 877 736-7787
Home > Blog > Case Studies

Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It

penguin-boxer-rightSide-300x300Make sure that your website is always ready for the real-time Penguin update. You can learn more in this FREE WEBINAR about what Google Penguin 4.0 (real-time Penguin) means for you.

The real-time Penguin update makes Link Risk Management - the practice of proactive link audits and disavows - more important than ever for your business. You can manage the risk of your backlink profile using the LRT Superhero Plan. This plan allows you to perform link risk management (link audit, link cleanup and link disavow boost), competitive research, professional SEO and backlink analysis for your own or your competitor's sites.

Penguin 3.0 Rollout Analysis and How to Understand It

Link Building Tips for Small Businesses

The Penguin Update number 6 – or Google Penguin 3.0 was rolled out in October 2014. 
This is an interesting in-depth rollout analysis by Certified LRT Xpert Bartosz Góralewicz who looks into

  • Impact of Negative SEO and Google’s success fixing it
  • Negative SEO victims he worked with – with detailed examples
  • Black Hat Affiliate Sites - including detailed examples
  • Penguin 3.0 Recovery Examples
  • Nerdy Penguin Update data
  • A Geeky Penguin Update Knowledge bonus
  • 3 things to look for while diagnosing Penguin 3.0
  • The future of Google Penguin updates
  • And so much more…

Today I am proud to present a long and detailed case-study that follows our past analysis work of the Penguin Updates, Penalties and SEO Tutorials.

 

Enjoy & Learn
Christoph C. Cemper

 

Avoid getting penalised by the real-time Google Penguin!

Keep your website safe with LinkResearchTools.

Table of contents

 

Penguin 3.0 Rollout Analysis and How to Understand It

On Saturday morning (EU time), we all noticed a lot of SERP movement. It is now confirmed: Penguin 3.0 has rolled out.

Still, even as I write this article, I have the feeling that I’m waiting for something more. I feel like I just unwrapped a huge fancy present only to find a pair of ugly socks in it.

So far, Penguin 3.0 has been a huge disappointment for me and many other webmasters.

 

Why is Penguin 3.0 a disappointment for me?

To this day I remember Saturday morning on October 5, 2013: the morning of Penguin 2.1. My mobile rang whole day, my inbox was full, and I couldn’t even think about looking at Skype or Facebook. That update was really a game-changer. It was huge. Penguin 2.0 recoveries were gigantic, and spammy sites were dropping like flies.

Now compare that to this past weekend of October 18, 2014, just after the Penguin 3.0 rollout.

 

 

 

A few most interesting comments

“Looks like some Panda, some Pirate and an unfinished Penguin at the moment.”

“No major change in our search engine traffic after we were hit by the last penguin update on 4th october 2013 and our traffic dropped instantly.”

“Penguin has not rolled out yet in the U.S.” (written Sunday October 19th)

“No UK result for me.”

And my personal FB status:

Also, Dejan Petrovic wrote an interesting post about his personal feelings about Penguin 3.0. I know he strongly believed Penguin 3.0 would surge SERPs. But after this weekend, he called Penguin 3.0 an underwhelming update.

Even BlackHatWorld.com forum users were surprisingly calm after Penguin 3.0. There were many interesting posts that you didn’t see with Penguin 2.1.

This is my favorite. It shows exactly why so many “white hat” webmasters are not too happy with Penguin 3.0.

 

A few important facts about Penguin

I’ve described the issues with a rolling new update in my Penguin 3.0 post (Btw, I was the first to blog about Penguin 3.0 in April 2013 :)). Let me quote it here:

Google Penguin

  1. It is not a human-driven algorithm
  2. It is based on links
  3. It does not inform website owners about being influenced by Penguin
  4. It only decreases the rankings of a website (of course, you can go up on the Penguin date, but only if a site above you was affected negatively by the update)
  5. It is not a penalty, it is an algorithm (according to the Googlers)
  6. You can’t recover quickly from the ranking decrease (you need to wait for a new Penguin update)
 

The reason behind the delay in launching Penguin 3.0

Negative SEO

It is difficult on the algorithm level to say if a website has a spammy link profile or is a victim of negative SEO. It is no longer a secret that, since Penguin 2.1, many webmasters adopted the technique of building links to their own website and to competitors.

We also have to deal with Kumar’s directories (he adds your website to thousands of SEO directories and asks for $2,000 - $3,000 to remove the links). He is very well known in the SEO community.  I work with more than 5 websites that were attacked by those directories.

 

New Black Hat linking strategies

But there is one more thing that was really underestimated. Most of the black hat tools are now designed to automatically add links to authority websites within the spammy articles.

All the problems listed above caused a huge delay with releasing Penguin 3.0. It is difficult to cope with those problems on an algorithmical level.

 

How did Google cope with the problems above?

Simple. They didn’t! 

Why not?

  1. I have access to data from some negative SEO victims and they were completely wiped from SERPs this Saturday.
  2. As I mentioned earlier, most of the white hat SEOs are really disappointed with spam still ranking high.
  3. If you go to e.g. www.blackhatworld.com or affiliate forums, you can hear many stories about spammy sites “surviving” Penguin 3.0.

Until Google figures out a better way to communicate with webmasters, auditing and monitoring links is an absolute must even for small businesses. Google created a strange situation where we have to use “designer anchor text” to look natural. On top of that, we need to monitor our link profile for attacks and (of course) we cannot forget about link building.

If you hate the game - you can always go with AdWords :)

 

Penguin 3.0 drops

OK, enough with the Penguin gossip, I’m going to show you a few websites hit by Penguin 3.0 this Saturday. I’ve divided the hit websites into 2 groups: Black Hat sites and Negative SEO victims.

 

Negative SEO victims

Unfortunately, there are cases where Penguin 3.0 returned a “false positive” and killed the wrong website.

 

Spammy sites “missed” by Penguin

There are many examples in this group, but I don’t need to publish those here. We were attacked for pointing spam to Google a few times already. Also, this Penguin was not too precise: there are examples in every niche :).

 

Black Hat Sites

There are cases where Penguin 3.0 actually did the right job: some websites with spammy link profile are not ranking anymore.

 

Example Black Hat Affiliate Sites that dropped with Penguin 3.0

www.acaiberries.it

This affiliate pills (Acai Berries) website ranked mostly with black hat links. Before Penguin 3.0, it was ranking quite well for weight loss-related terms in Italy.

Let’s see how Penguin 3.0 impacted this website.

Rank tracking screenshot

Google Webmaster Tools - Search Queries

This website was hit due to having almost 100% black hat links (mostly auto generated, spun content, etc.). There’s nothing good to support this website in Google “court.”

Link Detox score for acaiberries.it

As you see, the domain was a perfect Penguin victim candidate.

Google hiding links from webmasters?

This is disturbing. I’ve been seeing this for every website hit by Penguin: links from Google Webmaster Tools are gone!

Is it due to temporary data recalculation? Is it the “new normal”? In either case, it’s not the best solution to hide links from webmasters when they’ve just been hit.

 

Negative SEO sites dropping

For many (too many) of you, Kumar Vikis is too well known already. This is a scam artist, adding thousands of links to his “SEO” directories. Then he contacts the webmasters asking for money to take the links down.

It’s been going on for too long even though Google was informed about it numerous times. I am confident they didn’t take action yet because every time somebody gets attacked, his rankings spike (yeah, up) to then drop from either a manual penalty or from Penguin.

I won’t share the URL of this website because I don’t want to cause more problems for its owner. However, if any Googler would like to help out with solving this issue, feel free to contact me :).

Now here’s a local business with some links (mostly natural and a few niche related directories):

 

Rank tracking screenshot

 

Google Webmaster Tools

Unfortunately, as I write this article, Google Webmaster Tools didn’t refresh this site’s visibility. Again, the links are gone, just like in the previous example.

My team and I audited this website numerous times, and we disavowed thousands of backlinks so far. Still, new ones are showing up on a daily basis.

I’ve worked with them since ~March 2014, and we’ve managed to dodge many bullets since then. Let me show an example of their last Link Detox score (before and after).

 

Link Detox Risk Before the initial link audit

Keep in mind that the disavow file was already uploaded while running this report.

August 18th, 2014

 

Link Detox Risk After the initial link audit

September 8th, 2014

Now that looks quite ok. For September 8.

The funny thing is that between August 18th, 2014 and September 8th, 2014 we had some new directory links (the score would be even lower without them) and we assume more links were added later.

 

What to do now?

Penguin 3.0 hitting this site was partially my fault. I recommended auditing it once every 2 months. Doing it on a weekly/monthly basis seemed like too much for a local business. I heard Googlers say that Google will be able to diagnose Negative SEO attacks. I even heard many webmasters claim, that if it is negative SEO, they won’t be auditing the links and disavowing them since Kumar’s scam is so well known.

Many assumed that Google probably took care of many complaints about it on the Google Webmaster forum and stopped worrying about this scam.

Now the only solution is to audit the links on a weekly basis (this is crazy, isn’t it?) and wait for the next Penguin update (whenever that is).

I will definitely propose that my customer follow my Orca Technique on this website.

 

Negative SEO - Conclusion

I am sorry to say that negative SEO is still a real issue, regardless of what Googlers will say.
The new Penguin 3.0 was supposed to be the cure, but it turned out to be the poison for many white hat webmasters, too.

Ongoing Link Risk Management on a weekly basis seems mandatory.

 

Penguin 3.0 recoveries

With Penguin 2.1, recoveries were quite spectacular. This time, it is not the case. Almost all recoveries I see are slow, not the SERP nuke many were hoping for.

Data from Sistrix and SearchMetrics definitely confirms it.

Let’s take a look at Australia (I find it really interesting). There are more Panda recoveries here than Penguin 3.0 recoveries.

 

Penguin 3.0 recoveries - examples

United States

No. 1 - about.com (not Penguin)

No comment here. The screenshot above explains everything!

No. 2 - washingtonpost.com (not Penguin)

This is also not a Penguin 3.0 recovery.

No. 3 - rollingstone.com (not Penguin)

Their biggest visibility jump on October 19th 2014 is still not a Penguin recovery.

As you can see, there are many reasons for webmasters to be disappointed. Other markets looked quite similar….

 

Australia

No. 1 - ebay.com (not Penguin)

EBay.com being no. 1 confirms my theory. EBay is not a Penguin recovery website; they are recovering from Panda 4.0, yet they are no. 1 here.

No. 2 - onlymelbourne.com.au (not Penguin)

It is similar with eBay because they are also a Panda 4.0 victim that is now recovering.

No. 3 - kioskea.net

This looks like a Penguin recovery.

The third biggest jump in Australia got only 22% more visibility.

I remember Penguin 2.1 and recoveries and drops were far more drastic. With the data above, you can clearly see why so many webmasters remain frustrated after waiting for Penguin 3.0 for more than a year.

 

Recovery - case studies

So far, every single recovery case I looked at was completely different. I’ve noticed a few interesting factors that are worth mentioning. But before I do that, let me show you a few examples.

 

WholesaleClearance.co.uk

I’ve asked Karl - the website owner - to share his story and recovery. This website had a lot of manual work done to recover. The history goes back to Penguin 1.0, which is quite unusual.

A few words from Karl:

“My website was hit on April 24th, 2012. For the first week on, I did not notice there was a traffic drop as I was not keeping track of traffic because we paid an SEO company to work on this. I first noticed sales were poor and then learned that our website was hit by Penguin 1. I researched Penguin and tried to understand it. Link removals started in May 2012 after our site got hit again by Penguin. At the time, GWT was showing 600,000+ links, and it did not take long to work out the problems with over optimised anchor text links.

“One of the worst problems was a Blogspot template using keyword-rich anchor text links in the footer that was bought by our SEO company. I had to buy my website out of the SEO contract, and they never helped me to recover at all.

“By October 2012, link removals had been quite good. Links in GWT were now around 100,000 and the disavow tool was released so I uploaded the full list of our poor links to the file. In January 2013, out of desperation I filed for reconsideration (though I never received a manual action) and was surprised to see my reconsideration request failed because our site had a partial link penalty. After resending link removals and documenting everything, the partial was revoked in March 2013. GWT was now showing 17,130 links as of February 4, 2013 but still no recovery from Penguin.

“In October 2013 our site dropped again on the Penguin 2.1 date. In a Google Hangout with John Mueller, he confirmed that Penguin was having a major affect on my site and advised I clean more links. On his advice I audited 410 all inner pages that had SEO links pointing to them, as well as a fresh link audit which I now do every week. Over the last year this has helped find 200+ extra spam domains pointed to mine. With the help of Bartosz, Scrapebox and some of his scripts, we found a handful of other spam/poor quality links which have been disavowed or removed.

“Over the last 2 years we have managed to gain hundreds of great natural links from sites like the BBC, NBC, AOL News, Yahoo News, and ITV.”

I exchanged many emails with Karl over the last few months and I can say he probably put more work into his Penguin recovery than many professional SEOs.

 

What did the recovery look like?

Google analytics - Google Organic traffic only.

magazines research

And to show the traffic spike a little better, look at Google traffic (hourly traffic compared to Saturday the week before).

 

Ricochet recoveries

I saw a few websites where it seems they’ve recovered a little bit, but I don’t think they’ve recovered from Penguin. In some niches there were multiple websites penalized in the top 10, causing some serious SERP shake-ups.

It is still too early to show exact cases because I still see a lot of SERP movement today, with traffic shifting every few hours.

 

Orca Technique Follow Up

Link Building Tips for Small Businesses

Now this is something that many of you asked me about. For those of you who didn’t read my Orca Method article, it is basically a Penguin Update Recovery Technique I’ve created. It allows you to recover from Penguin quicker with a 301 redirect.

I’ve followed up on ~20 Orca Method websites I know about. After looking into the data, I can definitely say that whether you get hit by Penguin or not depends 100% on the link building strategy you adapt with a new, recovered domain. Four out of 20 domains got badly hit by Penguin. In every case it was caused by going back to old link building habits.

 

Nerdy Penguin Update data

I am not a big fan of listing exact issues targeted by Penguin like exact match anchor ratio or link types. I believe that since Penguin 2, it is much more complex. Still, for those of you looking for “ready to go” solutions, I can list a few clear patterns that will get you busted with Penguin.

  • No traffic links
    • SEO directories (I saw websites with only 10-15 directories being hit by Penguin)
    • Bookmarking sites
    • Article submission sites
    • Press Releases
    • etc.
  • Paid Guest posts
  • Auto generated links (for example xRumer, GSA, etc.)
  • Link networks
  • Mass comment/forum links (low quality)

Now, don’t get me wrong: I believe that guest posts can be a great base for your content marketing efforts and even link building. Still, 99% of those I see are really easy to spot on the algorithmical level.

All the examples listed above were main reasons from a site I investigated that was hit by Penguin. In my opinion, Penguin 3.0 targeted exactly the same patterns as Penguin 2.1, but it was softer.

 

Geeky Penguin Update Knowledge bonus

Here’s a quick Penguin knowledge test based on a comment from my own analysis.

If you don’t know why the screenshot above is funny, you will most probably be hit by the next Penguin update.

 

3 things to look for while diagnosing Penguin 3.0

  • Drops in rankings between October 17th and 18th.
  • Drops in traffic around October 18th
  • Links gone from Google Webmaster Tools (seems to be the pattern with Penguin 3.0)
 

The future of Google Penguin updates

Before the Penguin 3.0 release, we’ve heard a lot about Penguin being updated on a monthly basis. Unfortunately, today’s hangout with John Mueller didn’t confirm this information.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=Yi21yMBO9gI#t=2148

Later in the discussion, John mentioned that the holiday season is coming, and he is not expecting any major updates during that time.

Just when releasing this article, Pierre Far posted an update on his Google Plus profile saying that Penguin is not fully released.

I believe this statement was made to straighten out John Mueller’s answer from yesterday’s hangout, where he confirmed that Penguin was fully rolled out and he is not expecting it till next year (of course adding “most probably” a lot).

 

Summary

High expectations met with poor performance.

After going through the data above, you can clearly see that Penguin 3.0 is causing disappointment for white hat SEOs and relief for black hat SEOs.

I can see Googlers giving now hundreds of good (and a few great) reasons why it is not in their best interest to roll out a better update.

My point of view is simple

After a year of waiting for the new anti-spam algorithm from the world’s best IT engineers, I expected them to worry a little less about AdWords income, and a little bit more about thousands of businesses going down from Negative SEO. Now we have another year of
white hat SEOs ranking lower than black hat SEOs in the top 10...even after Penguin.

 

SEO is not optional

A year ago, after Penguin 2.1, there were hundreds of articles about SEO being dead. I never even considered this scenario then. Now I think Google is pushing webmasters to be even more dependent on good SEOs, regular link audits, backlink monitoring, etc.

You can have the best content ever and you can still get easily hit by Penguin or (in more and more cases) Panda as well (technical SEO issues). SEOs are not assisting with ranking the content now; they are protecting the digital assets. My role as SEO changed from promoting the content to protecting the content from Google’s wrath.

 

What are the options for webmaster’s negatively affected by Penguin 3.0?

If you got hit by Penguin 3.0, you definitely must proceed with a full link audit and ongoing link risk management (on a weekly basis)!

 

After this is done, you have two options:

  1. Wait until the next Penguin update for the recovery
  2. Use the Orca Method to recover quicker with a 301 redirect

Of course, there is always the third option: you can start with a new domain.

 

Finishing thoughts

I believe this is the first in-detail analysis of Penguin 3.0, and yet I feel like I barely scraped the surface.

With John Mueller claiming that Penguin is fully rolled out on Monday and they are not expecting it till next year, then Pierre Far posting the exact opposite Tuesday morning; we are getting closer to full schizophrenia. Basing your business decisions on it, can become quite
difficult… I honestly think that John Mueller is trying to help, but it seems like he is not really
informed about many things. Meanwhile, he is the only one authorized to speak to webmasters. For those of you taking it all too serious, I can recommend a simple test. I do that sometimes after listening to Googlers too much  Good luck!

For those of you taking it all too serious, I can recommend a simple test. I do that sometimes after listening to Googlers too much :)

Good luck!

PS: better start your next link audit now!

 

This case study was written by Bartosz Góralewicz, CEO at Elephate, and proud user of LinkResearchTools and Link Detox.

A word from Christoph C. Cemper

Certified LRT Xpert

Bartosz once again showed how fast and detailed he can work with us and I am proud to have him among our team of Certified LRT Professionals. Our goal is to provide our user community and clients with quality service and knowledge. Our Certified LRT Professionals and Xperts like Bartosz are key to achieving this goal.

I look forward to Bartosz’s future work, and I personally recommend working with him whenever you get the opportunity.

 

Certified LRT Xpert Bartosz Goralewicz

superhero smallWith the Superhero Plan you can perform link audits, link cleanup, link disavow boost, competitive research, professional SEO and backlink analysis for your own or your competitor's sites.

You can avoid a Google Penguin Penalty! Learn all about the Real-Time Google Penguin Update in this free webinar.

Join our free 21 Day Link Strategy Training below

Signup to receive snack sized bits of knowledge about Link Research Strategies, SEO Tactics & features of LinkResearchTools platform and technologies.

Bonus: signup you will also receive a free copy of the eBook "7 Golden Rules of Link Building" for immediate download.

Bartosz Goralewicz
Bartosz Góralewicz specializes in link audits. He does consulting mostly for corporate customers and large sites. You can find some of his case studies or interesting posts at https://goralewicz.com

36 Comments

  1. @SocialMeRay on October 21, 2014 at 8:57 pm

    RT @SEO: Google Penguin 3.0 Update – Analysis & How to Understand It http://t.co/hunx669PkH @lnkresearchtool #SEO http://t.co/qSLFxNotHc

  2. abu maram on October 21, 2014 at 9:53 pm

    There Arabic sites were hit by Penguin.
    My domain does not use methods of buying, selling or publishing.
    Whatever careful not to irregularities found penguin hits the site

  3. @lorystevensvb on October 21, 2014 at 9:59 pm

    RT @DonHalbert: Penguin 3.0 – did #Google get it all wrong? Small biz class action looming? #seo http://t.co/kjY0R03Fco

  4. @RichardPark199x on October 21, 2014 at 10:00 pm

    RT @DonHalbert: Penguin 3.0 – did #Google get it all wrong? Small biz class action looming? #seo http://t.co/kjY0R03Fco

  5. Dave on October 21, 2014 at 10:24 pm

    Hi Christoph, thanks for publishing your findings. I have a similar recovery story for a site which was still not performing following Penguin 1.0 in April 2012, which now finally has shown considerable improvement. My story follows a nearly identical path of what Karl experienced in terms of re-inclusion rejection and very in depth link removals that resulted in gradual improvement and eventual ‘recovery’.

    I have one other site which was hit hard by Penguin 3.0, with all terms moving from the first 2 pages to pages 8-14 and beyond. After doing a link audit, I’ve found that Kumar has a copycat working with .com.ar domains running the same scam. What are your clients doing in these instances, is disavow enough? Extremely frustrating!

  6. Timo Kojonen on October 21, 2014 at 10:28 pm

    International SEO – some observations regarding Penguin 3.0 and the
    first analysis published by LTR on October 21, 2014.

    Here in response to some issues that were discussed in the first analysis.

    a. Kumar directories: We used LTR to deal with this problem. Do like this: use LTR detox to see if your website is listed in one of these directories. If it is, disawow that particular directory and ALL of Kumar’s directories. To do that, you basically need to find a list of Kumar’s directories. Dig it up online.

    2. Bad anchor links: it is my impression that Penguin 3.0 is still recounting the rankings worldwide, region by region. It’s now Tuesday and during the past two days we went manually through our links (that we find using regional Google search engines, and disawowed sites featuring unnatural anchor links (in Spanish and German). As a result, the rankings seem to be moving up a bit still.

    3. Article websites: we used to have unique articles published in multiple languages on external article websites. Some of these articles were copied by other people who republished them elsewhere. Some of these sites were of low quality. During the pre-Penguin clean up process, we
    deleted many of these articles, or removed the links from them, or disawowed the article websites all together. On our own blogs we no longer publish stories with anchor links, just basic url links. This kind of approach seems to be acceptable by Google. Perhaps our articles do not help our rankings, but at least, they are not causing us trouble.

    The above methods helped us to recover from Penguin 2.1 now that Penguin 3.0 was released.

    Hope that these observations are helpful to the public. I underline that this just my own personal experience, based on one single website, Therapion.com, and one particular industry, online therapy and online counseling services. Our website has 15 language sections in separate subfolders each, and it targets our industry spesific key words in multiple regions.

    Kind regards, Timo

    Timo Kojonen
    Therapion Consulting, CEO
    http://www.therapion.com

  7. @WebWizeInc on October 21, 2014 at 10:34 pm

    Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It http://t.co/WeqI7b7GKL via @lnkresearchtool

  8. @HostingVirtuale on October 21, 2014 at 11:00 pm

    Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It http://t.co/ZdwBTbhQ8z via @lnkresearchtool

  9. @fusionbox on October 21, 2014 at 11:28 pm

    RT @SEO: Google Penguin 3.0 Update – Analysis & How to Understand It http://t.co/hunx669PkH @lnkresearchtool #SEO http://t.co/qSLFxNotHc

  10. @AntonieGeerts on October 22, 2014 at 12:51 am

    Great analyses from @lnkresearchtool on the latest google update. http://t.co/hzyRMHzXmW #negativelinkbuilding anyone? How long will it last

  11. @dejanseo on October 22, 2014 at 1:09 am

    An insanely detailed study of Pengin 3.0: http://t.co/0VOmeu8sDD by @bart_goralewicz

  12. Art on October 22, 2014 at 1:57 am

    I’m glad that you brought up this Vikis Kumar thing. The thing about this guy and Raj Kumar(it could be even the same person under two different names) that they create new directories using the same database on a daily basis. Once they told me it’s about 4500 directories. Google deindexed almost all their old directories, but their new directories still pop up in GWT. Google is trying hard to recognize these issues, but at the same time they’ve created an opportunity for people like this to take an advantage of their system and run an extortion business.

  13. sutoro on October 22, 2014 at 2:33 am

    thanks for sharing mr. i like seo but seo not exact science

  14. @subtlenetwork on October 22, 2014 at 3:14 am

    RT @dejanseo: An insanely detailed study of Pengin 3.0: http://t.co/0VOmeu8sDD by @bart_goralewicz

  15. @dodong_manting on October 22, 2014 at 4:38 am

    Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It http://t.co/ho2umaTOYu via @lnkresearchtool

  16. @davidherubel on October 22, 2014 at 6:14 am

    RT @venchito14: Penguin Update 3.0 Rollout Analysis – How to Understand It http://t.co/HbZ6FHvW5t via @linkresearchtools #penguin #linkbuil…

  17. @VeselinBorisov1 on October 22, 2014 at 7:38 am

    Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It http://t.co/EMfOoFZqLP via @lnkresearchtool

  18. @p_mcgee on October 22, 2014 at 8:52 am

    RT @SEOZib: Penguin Update 3.0 Rollout Analysis – How to Understand It http://t.co/qJ0yMEl4Oc #GooglePenguin #PenguinUpdate #SEO #SEM

  19. @FreshImpetusUK on October 22, 2014 at 9:55 am

    RT @SEOZib: Penguin Update 3.0 Rollout Analysis – How to Understand It http://t.co/qJ0yMEl4Oc #GooglePenguin #PenguinUpdate #SEO #SEM

  20. @gregfred8 on October 22, 2014 at 10:43 am

    Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It http://t.co/DkuOxQYOin via @lnkresearchtool

  21. @akamust on October 22, 2014 at 12:40 pm

    @cemper tweet 2 download doesn’t work http://t.co/39C3Q9sMTS

  22. @JimWatson9 on October 22, 2014 at 1:21 pm

    Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It http://t.co/biT2ruK3CM via @lnkresearchtool

  23. @BenjaminKaim on October 22, 2014 at 2:09 pm

    Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It: http://t.co/8Dnl5DTw4x via @lnkresearchtool

  24. @seogeekseo on October 22, 2014 at 3:59 pm

    Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It http://t.co/yOaxmZhAHw

  25. @tomyches on October 22, 2014 at 4:35 pm

    Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It http://t.co/2BGyFh7yhH vía @lnkresearchtool

  26. @Michael512 on October 22, 2014 at 11:12 pm

    Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It http://t.co/Bi0fnzHFN1 via @lnkresearchtool

  27. @iannaudesa on October 23, 2014 at 12:12 pm

    Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It http://t.co/SpIWT5EXgt via @lnkresearchtool

  28. @LiberoFusi on October 23, 2014 at 3:23 pm

    Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It – http://t.co/DNbsoumG92

  29. @M_Schwertfeger on October 25, 2014 at 12:02 pm

    Penguin Update 3.0 Rollout Analysis – How to Understand It http://t.co/IHaCG3NkRf

  30. @ewebers on October 26, 2014 at 10:27 pm

    RT @dejanseo: An insanely detailed study of Pengin 3.0: http://t.co/0VOmeu8sDD by @bart_goralewicz

  31. @sajuks on October 28, 2014 at 8:40 pm

    Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It http://t.co/86yC3K1J55 via @lnkresearchtool

  32. @SEO_cutie_pie on October 29, 2014 at 4:32 pm

    “SEOs are not assisting with ranking the content now; they are protecting the digital assets.” >> http://t.co/iJcxbyzZ4I

  33. @Im_JulianReyes on October 30, 2014 at 3:47 am

    #PenguinUpdate 3.0 Rollout Analysis and How to Understand It – http://t.co/LVuUJZfHhg. #SEO #Rankings #GoogleAnalytics

  34. @GMISophie on October 30, 2014 at 10:06 am

    Google Penguin 3.0 Update Rollout – Analysis and How to Understand It http://t.co/ZgXzzqgqEQ via @lnkresearchtool

  35. @adriansabah on November 11, 2014 at 4:24 pm

    Case studies for Penguin 3.0 http://t.co/WnbFb3zllD http://t.co/3C3B5XLTqj

  36. @Insistema on November 21, 2014 at 4:54 pm

    I primi effetti del #Pinguinos2015 … non sembrano aver sconvolto il mondo #SEO #Penguin3
    http://t.co/40hEVrTN6g

Leave a Comment